Malaysia Airlines Flight 370

(06-04-2014 19:47 )babelover48 Wrote:  how many days left?

The plane is believed to have crashed on Saturday 8 March.

More signals have been found this morning.

can the pings be picked by sonar?

yeah sonar can pick up pings how sonar works is it emits sound waves that bounce off objects and returns to the collector so any other sound will be picked up thats why in the submarine films they are always have silent running when they are in danger

The Australian searchers don't accept the Chinese reports of signals, according to today's media briefing. They said that signals sounding like pingers have been heard by an Australian ship today and that 2 distinct signals were heard, which is what they're looking for. The location is within the search area defined by the latest satellite analysis. The earlier Chinese location of reported pings was dismissed as being too far away.

That's not very nice of the Australians to rubbish the Chinese findings. Some of the news reports said that sounds can travel a long way underwater, so maybe the Chinese reports aren't incompatible with the Australians' own findings.

It's not just the distance though. The Australians seem sceptical of whether the method the Chinese were using, a listening device on the end of a pole, was even capable of detecting the pings in the first place.

(07-04-2014 13:39 )Glenn Miller Wrote:  It's not just the distance though. The Australians seem sceptical of whether the method the Chinese were using, a listening device on the end of a pole, was even capable of detecting the pings in the first place.

so dragging a microphone behind the boat is better than it on the end of a pole

(07-04-2014 14:42 )HannahsPet Wrote:  

(07-04-2014 13:39 )Glenn Miller Wrote:  It's not just the distance though. The Australians seem sceptical of whether the method the Chinese were using, a listening device on the end of a pole, was even capable of detecting the pings in the first place.

so dragging a microphone behind the boat is better than it on the end of a pole

Yes, significantly better.

They'd need a hell of a long pole to get down to the depth that a towed pinger locator operates at.

(07-04-2014 12:52 )whizzer Wrote:  Some of the news reports said that sounds can travel a long way underwater

Not that far though. The pingers have a range of 4km. In the right conditions it could be double that or triple that, or at an unlikely stretch possibly even 10 times, but even that would be only 40km. The Chinese are 600km away from where the Australians detected signals, so I can't see any way that both ships were hearing the same thing. Whatever the Chinese broomstick in the water picked up it wasn't what the Australians have been listening to.